PDP & Sandy Onor v. APC, Bassey Otu, Peter Odey & INEC - pre-election suit to disqualify the APC governorship ticket (2022-2023)
- Recorded status
- Closed
- Type / forum
- Electoral · Federal High Court, Calabar (Justice Rosemary Oghoghorie); Court Of Appeal, Calabar Division
- Case number
- FHC/CA/CS/142/2022
- Filed
- Not recorded
- Resolved
- 2023-02-04
Recorded outcome
He lost. By originating summons, the PDP and Onor asked the Federal High Court to disqualify the APC governorship candidate Bassey Otu and his running mate Peter Odey from the 2023 poll, alleging that Odey was not an APC member and held British citizenship (and, on appeal, that Otu had not left the PDP before joining the APC). On Thursday 24 November 2022 Justice Rosemary Oghoghorie held that the plaintiffs had not proved their case and struck the suit out. On 4 February 2023 the Court of Appeal, Calabar (panel presided over by Justice Raphael Chikwe Agbo) dismissed the appeal: a candidate cannot challenge another party's internal affairs, and party membership was not justiciable. No further appeal was found. The filing day and the Court of Appeal number were not found.
Read the evidence · 4 sources
- The Whistler (WordPress API)
2023-01-13: "The Court of Appeal, Calabar Judicial Division, has reserved judgment in a case filed by the Peoples Democratic Party governorship candidate, Sen. Sandy Onor against Sen Prince Bassey Otu, the flagbearer of the All Progressive Congress, APC."
The Court of Appeal, Calabar Judicial Division, has reserved judgment in a case filed by the Peoples Democratic Party governorship candidate, Sen. Sandy Onor against Sen Prince Bassey Otu, the flagbearer of the All Progressive Congress, APC.
- The Whistler (WordPress API)
2023-02-08: "Passing its judgement on February 4, 2023, the court of appeal dismissed the appeal by the PDP and its candidate saying it was lacking in merit."
Passing its judgement on February 4, 2023, the court of appeal dismissed the appeal by the PDP and its candidate saying it was lacking in merit.
- The Eagle Online
2022-11-24: "Senator Onor and the PDP, in an originating summons, had dragged the APC, Senator Otu, Hon. Odey and the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) as 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th defendants respectively before the court, alleging that the 3rd defendant was not a member of the APC and that he was also a British citizen and as such, was not qualified to run for any elective position in Nigeria."
Senator Onor and the PDP, in an originating summons, had dragged the APC, Senator Otu, Hon. Odey and the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) as 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th defendants respectively before the court, alleging that the 3rd defendant was not a member of the APC and that he was also a British citizen and as such, was not qualified to run for any elective position in Nigeria.
- Vanguard (via r.jina.ai mirror)
2022-12-01: "The Federal High Court, Calabar, gave its decision in a suit with Registration Number FHC/CA/CS//142/2022, filed by the PDP and its governorship candidate, Sandy Ojang Onor, challenging the eligibility of Senator Prince Otu and Peter Odey as governorship and deputy governorship candidates of their political party, the APC, respectively."
The Federal High Court, Calabar, gave its decision in a suit with Registration Number FHC/CA/CS//142/2022, filed by the PDP and its governorship candidate, Sandy Ojang Onor, challenging the eligibility of Senator Prince Otu and Peter Odey as governorship and deputy governorship candidates of their political party, the APC, respectively.
Record checked 15 Oct 2026

